Thursday, July 30, 2009

In Response to Rocky's Bru: Journo to Journo: How Low Can You Go?

Rocky's Bru: Journo to Journo: How Low Can You Go?

(Graphic of letter taken from Rocky's Bru)

I'm encouraged by the news (from Rocky's Bru) that a group of practising and former Malaysian journalists are writing to the Executive Chairman of Kumpulan Utusan, Tan Sri Mohamed Hashim Ahmad Makaruddin, to express their anger and disgust at the story on the late Yasmin Ahmad that the tabloid Kosmo! ran on July 27th, 2009. As they write in their email seeking fellow journalists' support for their letter: "Let's uphold the kind of journalism that this country so desperately needs."

Irregardless of whether it is based on the truth or not, the article, headlined "Takdir Yasmin", breached not only the journalist's code of ethics, but standards of human decency as well.

Since a journalist's first obligation is to seek truth and report it, why is this article in Kosmo! a breach of journalistic ethics? Because even if it is true, it violates another principle that journalists are obliged to uphold:
Minimize Harm - Ethical journalists treat sources, subjects and colleagues as human beings deserving of respect.
According to this principle, journalists should:
  • Show compassion for those who may be affected adversely by news coverage. Use special sensitivity when dealing with children and inexperienced sources or subjects.
  • Be sensitive when seeking or using interviews or photographs of those affected by tragedy or grief.
  • Recognize that gathering and reporting information may cause harm or discomfort. Pursuit of the news is not a license for arrogance.
  • Recognize that private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials and others who seek power, influence or attention. Only an overriding public need can justify intrusion into anyone’s privacy.
  • Show good taste. Avoid pandering to lurid curiosity.
  • Be cautious about identifying juvenile suspects or victims of sex crimes.
  • Be judicious about naming criminal suspects before the formal filing of charges.
  • Balance a criminal suspect’s fair trial rights with the public’s right to be informed.
(From the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics)

In the case of Kosmo's article, the people behind it have violated this principle in at least four ways:
  1. They have treated the memory of their subject, a recently deceased person no longer able to tell her side of the story, with disrespect, making allegations that may (given prevailing societal attitudes, prejudiced though they may be) diminish how she is remembered by Malaysians, and expose her family to odium.
  2. They showed little compassion to her family and scant regard for the potential harm to her aged and frail mother.
  3. They did not demonstrate any overriding public need that could have justified such an intrusion into their grief and privacy.
  4. The mode in which they presented their report suggests that they have pandered to lurid curiosity, perhaps motivated by the need to sell newspapers.
It is therefore fitting that the journalists' letter rebukes Tan Sri so: "...if your objective is to practice ethical journalistic conduct and act with humanity, you have failed - miserably." They go on to ask him, "How much of your personal honour are you willing to part with in order to increase your circulation?"

All of us will be held to account for everything we write, before the One who reads and edits us all. In the meantime, Kosmo and its journalists involved with this article are accountable to us, their readers and colleagues. Let us make it clear to them that we will not stand by to see ethics breached.

Is their story true or false? I wholeheartedly second blogger Kama's wise words, words worthy of repeating and remembering (from here):
"...Yasmin has gone to meet her Maker. Our time will come soon. Seharusnya kita sadaqah Al-fatihah untuk arwah Yasmin and not go into this silly polemic about her gender. May her soul be placed among the blessed. Amin."
Now, may I pose this question, not to Kosmo!, but to all of us who are outraged by Kosmo's article:

Do any of us believe that Kosmo has a monopoly on unethical journalism in Malaysia?

First let's see what the principles of ethical journalism that we are bound to uphold are (adapted from the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics):
The duty of the journalist is to further public enlightenment as the forerunner of justice and the foundation of democracy, by seeking truth and providing a fair and comprehensive account of events and issues. Conscientious journalists from all media and specialties strive to serve the public with thoroughness and honesty. Professional integrity is the cornerstone of a journalist's credibility. Journalists should:

1. Seek Truth and Report It - Journalists should be honest, fair and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting information.

2. Minimize Harm - Ethical journalists treat sources, subjects and colleagues as human beings deserving of respect.

3. Act Independently - Journalists should be free of obligation to any interest other than the public's right to know. [Advocacy journalists may of course intentionally and transparently adopt a non-objective viewpoint.]

4. Be Accountable - Journalists are accountable to their readers, listeners, viewers and each other.

The letter to Tan Sri Hashim begins "July 27th, 2009 marked the darkest day in Malaysian journalistic history yet." In the light of the above, haven't there been days in Malaysian journalistic history just as dark as 27/7/09?

How about in the days just before the 1990 general elections, when "then opposition politician Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah was depicted as selling out Muslim interests to Christians merely because he was photographed wearing ethnic Kadazan cultural headgear on which was a symbol resembling a cross. The photograph was splashed in the media and Razaleigh had little chance to counter the allegations". Utusan Melayu published the picture for three days, and Berita Harian's headline on May 19, 1990 was "Ku Li Junjung Salib".

How about something more recent, just eight days ago (22/07/09), when Pakatan Rakyat's position regarding the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the death of Teoh Beng Hock was grossly misrepresented in the pages of the New Straits Times?

Why do we not speak up and act against journalistic misconduct by all news outlets (including our own)? Why are we being selective? Surely our professional ethics apply equally to all, no matter what the victims' (and perpetrators') station in life is? Or is it just a case of double standards and whose ox is being gored?

So, let me put the question back to all the journalists who are rightly outraged at Kosmo: How much of our personal honour are we willing to part with in order to increase our circulation (prospects, promotions, popularity, etc.)?

In other words, when our Editor reads us, will He find us fit to print, or fit to spike?

Lest we be found wanting, we must be mindful of what we ourselves and our colleagues write. For the sake of our integrity, we must speak and act whenever and wherever we see journalistic ethics being compromised, and we must do so in spite of our political beliefs and personal interests. Let's uphold the kind of journalism that this country so desperately needs.

Malaysian Heart

You can download a printable copy of the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics in full here (in PDF format).

(I am a member of Hartal MSM, a mediawatch group which had its beginnings in December 2007 in The People's Parliament, an initiative convened by civil rights lawyer Haris Ibrahim. The group seeks to promote a free and fair media as an impetus to Malaysia's stalled nation-building process. The views expressed here are solely my own)


  1. Dear MH

    No matter how grandeur the apology made by Kosmo, the damage has been done and it is beyond repair - teribbly and so painfully especially to the family of Allahyarhamah Yasmin Ahmad.

    Sadly, journos whom i thought are the kind of professionals, who would write for the cause of the people, practised double standard in other matters but showed their solidarity when the issue is close to their heart. How selfish.

    I do hope these people would be enlightened with your honest heart to heart writing.

    "There can be no friendship without confidence; and no confidence, without integrity"

  2. Dear Fisha,

    That's so true. Bak kata pepatah, "terlajak perahu boleh diundur, terlajak kata buruk padahnya". In this case the padah is being suffered by her family and loved ones. May they be comforted in their time of grief

    You're quite right, expressing outrage at Kosmo while ignoring flagrant journalistic misconduct everywhere else smacks of double standards and hypocrisy. We need to expose it wherever it takes place, even it is from a cause close to our hearts.

    m"May I have Integrity"h

  3. Sir, I have chosen you as my Friday Guest Blogger. YOU deserve that and it is an honor for me to feature YOU.

  4. I am humbled, Sir. May I be worthy.

  5. Dear MH

    Although i have not met Yasmin personally, i am deeply saddened by her untimely death. Yasmin was a fantastic storyteller, free from racial biasness and always showing us the way to a united malaysia in it's splendid diversity !
    May she rest in peace.

    At a time when the family was mourning and in grief for their loss; words of comfort, love and understanding would have been helpful.

    But the language in the gutter by Kosmo was disrespectful and despicable to all sensible Malaysians! Have they not have any decency and dignity left?

    After 50 years of independence, is this what we have breed and nurtured in our MSM?

    God save our beloved tanahair!

  6. I would have been more qualified sending that letter to the chief of the Utusan Group as I have consistently criticised them for all their past failings as well. Where were/are these 5 journalists when Utusan repeatedly cotinue to churn out inciteful, hate filled articles? When these 5 journalists find that they can condone all the non-reporting of events when in fact events have happened that is just as bad. MSM obviously collaborates with the powers that be that what is not reported "never happened". So tehre is no need for any response. Like the recent series in Malaysia-Today on the MAS scandal over Tajuddin Ramli's plundering of MAS' assets. Those were police reports after al. Funnilly even Malasyiakini has not taken up the expose in Malaysia-Today. No MSM report, no response necssary from the authorities, close file!! Journalists know this, and yet silence!!!

  7. Dear MH,

    That was gutter-journalism by the Utusan Group/Kumpulan Utusan. They must be experiencing very low self-esteem that they need to even tear down a defendless Yasmin Ahmad who is dead and gone. Downright disgraceful!

    I did not know of of Yasmin's gender problem before but now that I do, I have more admiration for her. I think Yasmin had done tremendously well touching the lives of many with her adverts and movies which were so down to earth and real.

    One can tell she had such fantastic sense of humor as she reminded us that if we bother to look back at our many life experiences, we will just as able to laugh at ourselves and at our sillyness!

    For a woman, I think she carried herself remarkably well - graceful, poised and gentle that even many of the female gender find it hard to immitate.

    She will be sadly missed.


How to Paste Text into Comment Boxes

Google seems to have disabled pasting text (including ctrl-v) into blogger comments boxes in Firefox. The good news is that:
1. You can still copy paste using Internet Explorer (I successfully tried it with IE7)
2. With Firefox, you can still "Drag and Drop" text into the comment form. I have successfully dragged and dropped text from MS Word, websites (HTML) and from ScribeFire (plain text and HTML). Just do the following:

a) reduce the size of the window you want to take the text from, and place it near the comment box
b) Highlight the required text with cursor
c) Click on the highlighted text and drag it over to the comment box and drop it there.

Happy commenting!